WAR AND THE TECH TRAP
Introduction
There is one thing analysts and policymakers across the spectrum seem to agree on and that is the future of warfare will be determined by technology. Hypersonic missiles, quantum computing, drone swarms, and artificial intelligence have all been termed as transformative technologies that will shape battlefields, remake strategies and upend established military doctrines.
Without question, these technologies are already having a tremendous impact. In Gaza, Iran, Lebanon, Ukraine and elsewhere, everyone with the capacity to employ artificial intelligence and autonomous systems has done so in all domains and at times in massive numbers.
There is also no question that any armed force must ensure that they possess the most sophisticated and cutting-edge capabilities available. Further, to continue developing and operationalizing these technologies, defence planners need to prioritize scaling , integrate them and develop innovative tactical concepts to employ them.
As a result, the prevailing security environment is affected by rapid technological advancements and the resultant changing character of war. The drive to develop new technologies is relentless, expanding to more actors with lower barriers of entry, and moving at accelerating speed. New commercial technology is changing the character of war. As many technological developments are coming from the commercial sector means that competitors and non-state actors also have access to them.
The ongoing conflicts have demonstrated with brutal clarity just how much warfare has changed. The breakneck pace of technological innovation makes it possible to roll out new autonomous weapons, AI algorithms, and other sophisticated systems that are updated constantly.
Tech Trap
But an equally significant risk exists: called, “the technology trap,” in which policymakers develop a misplaced sense of certainty about how innovations will change war and what warfare will look like in the future, while not paying enough attention to the unchanging fundamentals of war.
A case in point being the Iran war which was launched without a clear rationale and with a constantly shifting set of objectives as the US felt their superior technology could deliver.
The downside is that faith in technological answers can obscure the most fundamental questions. Who kills, who dies, and who decides? Fixating on technology might make them lose sight of the essential elements of war. AI promises faster decision-making and execution but there is also a dark side as evident with the targeting of the school in Minabin Iran, hence is a faster war a wiser war?
More than 50 years ago, Michael Howard the military historian wrote about future wars. “I am tempted indeed to declare dogmatically that whatever doctrine the Armed Forces are working on now, they have got it wrong,” he wrote. “I am also tempted to declare that it does not matter that they have got it wrong. What does matter is their capacity to get it right quickly when the moment arrives.”
But Howard may have been optimistic about the costs of getting it wrong. Predicting the role of technology in future wars has become even harder due to the speed, scale, and complexity of contemporary technological progress. In the past, transformative innovations tended to be expensive at their outset in resources or personnel or required specialized knowledge and skills accessible to only a few. By contrast, many of today’s technologies have low barriers to entry: they are cheap to produce, and access to the knowledge necessary to make them has been democratized and globalized.
In 2018 the US National Defense Strategy, anticipated that a few primarily high-end capabilities including advanced computing, artificial intelligence, robotics, hypersonics, and biotechnology—would “ensure we will be able to fight and win the wars of the future.”
Instead, what emerged were conflicts such as the war in Ukraine, Gaza and Iran which can be described as World War I meets World War III. While sophisticated ballistic missiles have wreaked havoc as have precision-guided glide bombs delivered by fighter aircraft out of the range of air defences. At the same time, however, lethal bombs are dropped by drones and drones destroyed some of Russia’s strategic bombers, while on the other hand one of the most effective anti-drone defences consists of nets and cope cages being put over critical assets and defences.
A sense of certainty that sophisticated tech would dominate battlefields has produced consequences that few would have predicted.
War Remains A Human Endeavor
An obsession with technology can obscure the precept that war remains a human endeavor. As Carl von Clausewitz said, “War is not the action of a living force upon a lifeless mass . . . but always the collision of two living forces.” The nature of war has not changed. Its language is violence and technology simply offers new and different ways to communicate. Therefore, the fundamental questions of war remain salient regardless of technological change: What are the ends (particularly with respect to politics), the ways, and the means?
Clausewitz talked “the centre of gravity “the hub of all power and movement, on which everything depends.” This is where an opponent’s power originates, so it needs to be the focus of a military’s attention and resources.
The last few weeks have revealed that the hub of power lies in various systems such as banks in Paraguay, deep freezers in Europe and air control in the US. Microsoft servers were down. All these systems depend on technology and are susceptible to attacks by technology.
A way to avoid the technology trap is to conduct deliberate, impartial, and regular reviews of lessons learned during and between wars. Iran studied the attacks that Israel and the US carried out on its nuclear sites in 2025. Recognizing that another war would likely pose a serious risk to its regime, it decentralised command and control and as a result it was able to deal with the February attack.
The ways and means of warfare are influenced by technology but have not been fundamentally changed by it.
Conclusion
While tech may dominate, it is important to bear in mind that even though the means of warfighting will keep changing, the fundamental nature of war will not.
Presently there is no denying the fact that a human being shall remain supreme in deciding the outcome of a conflict. While technology facilitates the application of power, it is a human whose dexterity in exploiting technology actually matters and is the deciding factor. There is no doubt that technology determines how wars can be fought but war is and will continue to remain a contest of human will.















Comments